There is this controversy on the
identification of the 17th Karmapa within the Kagyu Lineage. Two senior disciples of the
16th Karmapa have identified two different boys as the reincarnation of the 16th Karmapa.
Tai Situ Rinpoche has identified Urgyen Trinley Dorje from Tibet whereas Sharma Rinpoche
has identified Thaye Dorje from India. As a result, there now appears to be two 17th
Karmapas. This has given rise to much confusion amongst the disciples. What is worse is
that when the Khenpos and Rinpoches of the Kagyu Lineage were asked to clarify the
situation by their disciples, they mostly said they recognised both of them. But Tai Situ
Rinpoche and Sharma Rinpoche do not recognise each other¡¦s choice as the reincarnation
of the 16th Karmapa. I think controversial matter of this kind should be clarified by
religious elders of the Kagyu Tradition. Recently, I was honoured with an opportunity to
interview Thrangu Rinpoche. Not only is he a religious elder, he was also a religious
teacher of Situ Rinpoche and Sharma Rinpoche. I think he is the best qualified Kagyu
religious elder to clarify and inform us the truth.